The story of Ontario’s most notorious killers is coming to the big screen, but it’s not going to be easy.
The film, based on the events surrounding Karla Homolka and Paul Bernardo, is causing controversy among Canadians who say the film is an attempt to exploit and capitalize on these tragic events.
Michael Sellers the producer and one of the writers on the film, is facing the controversy head-on and is on a mission to have the film released in Canada.
In early October, Sellers screened the film privately for lawyer Tim Danson, who represents the families of slain teenagers Leslie Mahaffy and Kristen French.
“I went up to Toronto to do the private screening for Tim Danson on behalf of the families, and they acknowledged that the film is not something they are going to oppose.” said Sellers. “That doesn’t mean that they endorse it by any stretch of the imagination, but they understand and acknowledge that it hasn’t taken a tawdry exploitation approach.”
Danson had originally vowed to take legal action against the movie on grounds that should it depict the rape and murders of French and Mahaffy, it would qualify as child pornography.
Since the news of the film became public, Sellers has received close to a thousand e-mails opposing his film. Surprisingly, only a single email from Arkansas was sent by an American against the release of the film.
The film was set to premiere at this summer’s Montreal World Film Festival on opening night, but was later pulled when organizers faced heat from corporate sponsors including Air Canada for the selection of the film. Sellers was not shocked by the decision of the struggling film festival to pull the film.
“I was surprised actually that they accepted it,” recalled Sellers. “There’s an issue there of whether arts lovers want corporations like Air Canada determining what can be seen or not seen in film festivals, which traditionally have been venues for provocative movies. I mean last year at the Toronto Film Festival they had that film about the guys that skin the cat alive.”
Premier Dalton McGuinty, who has spoken out against the film and has urged Ontarians to boycott the movie, congratulated the film festival for its decision to pull the film.
“Karla, obviously, the film not the person, just invokes very raw and deeply felt emotions. Yes, I believe that we have a right to make the film, the film has the right to be seen, but people shouldn’t be forced to see it,” said Sellers. “I believe that the families, in one sense, have taken a rational approach and I wish that other people who are trying to block the film would take a similar approach. At the same time, I’m respectful of the deeply felt emotions that people have on this and I don’t feel that the family’s moves trumps everybody else’s. The families are a big part of this, but this situation affected the lives and psyches of many people and not just the families.”
Playing the lead role of Karla Homolka is Laura Prepon, who is well known for her character ‘Donna’ on the television comedy That 70’s Show. In the role of Paul Bernardo is Misha Collins, a relatively unknown actor who had a recurring role on the first season of 24.
Although none of the actions of Paul Bernardo and Karla Homolka have been fictionalized in the film, the creators of the film were legally not allowed to depict Karla’s parents or her sister Laura. Instead a fictional elderly couple was created to carry out the actions which were done in real life by Karla’s parents.
“The actions that are depicted all actually happened, but they were transferred to another character,” said Sellers. “We’ve looked at all the true crime movies that have been done lately, and I don’t think any one has been done as accurately. We really felt that it was extremely important to stick to the story.”
The names of the victims however, were not used, and instead the film’s creators created fictional names to represent the girls which were slain.
“Legally it was not required because they are deceased, they’re part of the public record, but we felt there was no value to the film in using their names and we know the families of the victims prefer they not be used,” said Sellers.
Second-year General Arts and Sciences student Luca Lombardi has been following the film closely and is looking forward to seeing the film once it’s released.
“I want to see the film to make sure that she’s not portrayed as an innocent person, but as what I think she is, a truly violent criminal person,” said Lombardi. “The government shouldn’t be standing in the way of this film being released. It’s not their choice to decide what the public should and should not see. They should let the film be released and let the public decide if this is a film that is appropriate for them or not. To go ahead and let the government start deciding what we should be viewing is crazy.”
Sellers hopes that once the film is released, people will view it with an open mind and better understand the events which took place surrounding Karla.
“Karla will become a three-dimensional character. Any time you make a movie, you spend two hours trying to depict the person’s choices and existence, they’re going to emerge as a more rounded character and you’re going to gain insight into their psychological process. Humanity is based upon people making choices that make sense to them at the time they make them,” said Sellers. “No matter how evil someone is, they have a point of view and there are those in the world who feel there may be some value in exploring evil. I haven’t made a career out of it. This is the first time I’ve made a movie that precisely does this, and I don’t see myself constantly repeating this process but I think what people need to understand is that this film will deliver insight into her character which helps in a lot of ways, helps to understand the process which she went through.”
A Canadian distribution deal that would get the film into theatres is almost complete and should be announced in early December. Sellers expects the film to be released sometime after Christmas.
PUBLISHED IN HUMBER ET CETERA 11.10.05








